You found the apartment, the mortgage is approved, and you and your partner are about to sign. You're a team in every way that matters — you've just never gotten around to a wedding, or you've decided marriage isn't for you. Then the attorney at the closing table asks a question you haven't thought about: "How do you want to take title?" And suddenly you realize you have no idea what happens to this home if one of you dies, gets sick, or the relationship ends.
Here's the uncomfortable truth: New York law gives married couples a thick safety net of automatic rights. Unmarried partners get almost none of it. The good news is that every one of those protections can be built by hand — you just have to actually build them.
Key takeaways
- Unmarried partners have no automatic inheritance rights in New York — if your partner dies without a will, their share of the home goes to their blood relatives, not to you.
- How you take title (joint tenants with rights of survivorship vs. tenants in common) decides what happens to the home at death — and the default is usually the wrong one for couples.
- A healthcare proxy and power of attorney are essential: without them, your partner may have no legal right to make medical or financial decisions for you.
- A will or trust plus a cohabitation agreement fills in everything the marriage license would have covered automatically.
Why the law treats you as legal strangers
New York's intestacy rules — the statute that decides who inherits when there's no will — recognize spouses, children, parents, and siblings. A partner of twenty years appears nowhere on that list. If your partner dies without a will, their half of the home passes to their closest relatives, and you could find yourself co-owning your own kitchen with a sibling-in-law you've met twice, or facing pressure to sell. There is no "common law marriage" formed inside New York, no elective share for partners, and no automatic priority to serve as administrator of their estate.
How you take title matters enormously
When two unmarried people buy property in New York, the deed usually says one of two things. As tenants in common, each of you owns a separate share that passes through your own estate at death — meaning through probate, and to whoever your will (or the intestacy statute) says. As joint tenants with rights of survivorship, the survivor automatically owns the whole property the moment the other dies, outside of probate entirely. If the deed is silent, New York presumes tenants in common for unmarried buyers — often exactly what a couple does not want. Neither choice is automatically "right": survivorship is simple and protective, but tenants in common may fit better if you contributed unequal down payments or have children from prior relationships you want to provide for. The point is to choose deliberately, not by default.
The documents that stand in for a marriage license
A short stack of documents can give you most of what marriage would have provided. A will lets each of you leave your share of the home — and everything else — to the other, and lets you name each other as executor. A revocable trust can go a step further, holding the home so it passes to your partner without probate at all, with a backup plan if you both die. A healthcare proxy names your partner to make medical decisions if you can't; without one, New York's default rules put relatives ahead of your partner unless the partner qualifies as a 'domestic partner' under the statute (PHL 2994-d) — and even then a proxy avoids having to prove that status in a crisis. A power of attorney lets your partner pay the mortgage and manage accounts if you're incapacitated. Finally, a cohabitation or property agreement — think of it as a business plan for the house — spells out who paid what, how expenses are shared, and what happens if you split up, so a breakup doesn't turn into a lawsuit over the deed. Coordinating these pieces is the heart of good estate planning for unmarried couples.
Don't forget the beneficiary forms
Retirement accounts, life insurance, and payable-on-death bank accounts pass by beneficiary designation, not by will. If your 401(k) still names a parent or an ex, that's who collects — regardless of what your will says. An unmarried partner also doesn't receive the special treatment spouses get with inherited retirement accounts, which makes the designations, and sometimes trust planning around them, worth an attorney's review. If either of you owns other significant assets, layering in asset protection planning can keep the home safe from one partner's creditors or business risks, too.
How Schwartsman Law Group can help
Schwartsman Law Group helps unmarried couples across New York take title the smart way and build the wills, trusts, proxies, and agreements that protect both partners — before the closing, not after a crisis. Founding attorney Marianna Schwartsman and her team serve clients from offices in Brooklyn, Manhattan, and Manhasset, in English, Spanish, and Russian, and can tailor a plan to your specific situation. Call +1 212 518 3868, email ms@schwartsmanlaw.com, or request a free consultation — a single planning meeting before you sign the deed can save years of trouble later.