Probate · Trusts & Estates · Planning, Administration & Asset Protection Brooklyn · Manhattan · Queens · Bronx · Staten Island · Long Island
+1 212 518 3868 ms@schwartsmanlaw.com
Save our contact

We Just Had a Baby — Who Would Raise Them If Something Happened to Us?

Updated August 9, 2026 · 5 min read

You just brought a baby home. Somewhere between the two a.m. feedings and figuring out the car seat, a thought crosses your mind that you push away almost as fast as it arrives: if something happened to both of us, who would raise this child? Nobody enjoys sitting with that question. But answering it takes one conversation and a few documents — and not answering it hands the decision to a judge who has never met your family.

Here's what New York law actually does for new parents, and the short list of things worth putting in place while the baby naps.

Key takeaways

  • The most reliable way to say who should raise your child is to name a guardian in a properly signed will; a recorded written designation under SCPA 1710 or a standby-guardian designation under SCPA 1726 are the other statutory routes. Without one, the Surrogate's Court chooses among whoever comes forward.
  • Minors can't inherit money outright, so without a trust, funds left to your child can end up under court supervision and then be handed over in full at 18.
  • A trust for your child — often paired with life insurance payable to it — lets a trustee you choose manage the money and release it on your schedule, not the state's.
  • Young parents need incapacity documents too: a power of attorney and healthcare proxy cover the far likelier scenario where one of you is alive but unable to act.

Naming a guardian: the decision only you should make

If both parents die without naming anyone, New York's Surrogate's Court appoints a guardian based on the child's best interests — after relatives apply, sometimes several of them, sometimes ones you'd never have chosen, and occasionally in open disagreement with each other. Naming a guardian in your will puts your voice at the center of that proceeding; courts give a fit parent's designation great weight. Choose for parenting values, not obligation — the godparent isn't automatically the right pick, and neither is the oldest sibling. Name a backup in case your first choice can't serve, and tell the people you've chosen. Some parents also separate roles: one person raises the child while another manages the money, which keeps love and accounting from having to live in the same house.

Why you shouldn't leave money directly to a child

A minor can't legally receive an inheritance or life insurance payout outright. If your child is named as a beneficiary directly — or inherits because there was no plan — the funds typically end up restricted under court oversight until age 18, with the guardian needing permission for many uses along the way. Then, on the child's eighteenth birthday, the entire remaining amount is released to a brand-new adult in one lump sum. Most parents, asked directly, do not want their eighteen-year-old receiving everything at once. The default rules simply don't match how families think.

A trust plus life insurance: the working plan

The fix is straightforward. Your wills (or a revocable living trust) create a trust for your children, and you choose the trustee — the person or institution that manages the money, pays for the child's education, housing, and health, and distributes the remainder at ages you select, perhaps in stages through the twenties or thirties. Then you point the money at it: life insurance is the engine of most young families' plans, because it converts an affordable premium into real security, and naming the trust as beneficiary means the payout lands under your rules instead of a court's. Retirement accounts and other assets can be coordinated the same way. This is bread-and-butter estate planning, and for families whose child has a disability, a supplemental needs trust designed through special needs planning protects government benefits the child may rely on later.

The documents for while you're alive

For most young parents the bigger risk isn't dying — it's being alive and unable to act. A durable power of attorney lets your spouse or another trusted person manage accounts, insurance, and bills if you're incapacitated. A healthcare proxy names who makes medical decisions for you, and a HIPAA release lets doctors talk to your family. Without these, your spouse can face a court guardianship proceeding just to handle your affairs — an expensive, public detour at the worst possible moment. The whole package for a young family is a handful of documents, prepared once and reviewed every few years or when life changes.

How Schwartsman Law Group can help

Schwartsman Law Group builds exactly these plans for new parents — wills that name guardians, trusts that hold life insurance for children, and the powers of attorney and healthcare proxies that protect the years in between. Founding attorney Marianna Schwartsman and her team serve families from offices in Brooklyn, Manhattan, and Manhasset, in English, Spanish, and Russian. If you'd rather have it done right than keep pushing the thought away, call +1 212 518 3868, email ms@schwartsmanlaw.com, or request a free consultation.

MS
Marianna Schwartsman, Esq.
New York trusts and estates attorney. Fordham Law, Summa Cum Laude. Formerly of Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP and Meltzer Lippe. More about the firm →
FAQ

FAQ

What happens if both parents die without naming a guardian in New York?

The Surrogate's Court appoints a guardian based on the child's best interests, choosing among relatives or others who petition. The court gives the greatest weight to a parent's choice when it is made in a validly executed will or an acknowledged and recorded written designation (deed) under SCPA 1710 (a standby-guardian designation under SCPA 1726 covers a parent's incapacity as well as death); otherwise the judge chooses among whoever petitions.

Should I name my child as my life insurance beneficiary?

Generally no. A minor can't receive the proceeds outright, so the money would sit under court-supervised restrictions and then be paid out entirely at 18. Naming a trust for your child instead lets your chosen trustee manage and release the funds on your terms.

Can the guardian who raises my child be different from the person who manages the money?

Yes, and many parents deliberately split the roles — a guardian for day-to-day parenting and a separate trustee for finances. It adds a layer of accountability and lets each person do what they're best at.

Have a question we didn't cover here? Browse our Quick Answers — short, direct answers to the questions New York families search most.

More questions answered → All questions A–Z

Protect What You've Built

Schedule your free consultation today. Meet us in Brooklyn, Manhattan, or Manhasset — or by phone or video.

Request Free Consultation
+1 212 518 3868